To me a lot depends on why I feel it was a dud punt.
Yes, I will often review in my head aspects as there are times when it may be a dud because of me and not the lady involved. Was I really wanting to go and have the fun or was it just something to kill time type of thought?
For me, if the dud aspect was no connection that is a 2 way street as while yes, the lady has a level of responsibility to try to connect and make the time pleasant, I also have the responsibility to be receptive and try to return teh connection attempts. Sometimes it works and build, sometimes ti does not and when that occurs I have to accept level of blame and so I may pass on that lady but not the place.
However, where the atmoshpere or the place itself is the issue, I will often pass totally for any other visist but remembering that it is a single shop, sometimes sister shops are not the same level of issue so I may try a sister shop.